Nonpartisan. Oath-bound. We endorse no candidate and no party.

Taking shape

Not yet interfering with how the election runs.

Refusal to certify results

What is it?

Local or state officials refuse or delay certifying results to stall the end of an election. Certification is a mandatory duty that courts can compel, so the harm is delay and doubt, not a changed result.

Where does it stand?

Early signs seen: 3 of 3

Signs it is happening: 0 of 3

  • None
  • Taking shape
  • Happening now

States

  • Alaska
    • Early sign A federal lawsuit asks a court to block a state from certifying a result. Alaska, U.S. Senate race: DOJ sued the state and its elections director in federal court in Anchorage
  • California
    • Early sign An election official tries to stall the county declaration of a primary without a legal basis. Shasta County, California, at the June primary
  • New Mexico
    • Early sign A local official says publicly they will not rule out refusing to certify. Otero County, New Mexico, where the county refused to certify in 2022
  • Texas
    • Early sign A federal lawsuit asks a court to block a state from certifying a result. Texas, all federal races: Potter County GOP suit in federal court in Amarillo seeks a hand count of every ballot before certification

Nationwide

Nothing seen at the national level yet.

What changed?

  • Florida ordered a recount in the 27th District for 10 a.m. Monday, Nov. 9, at Miami-Dade elections headquarters in Doral, a day earlier than first reported, CBS Miami reports Nov. 8. Garcia sits on the canvassing board and will not recuse. No hearing is set on Rodriguez's suit.
  • Colom led Hyde-Smith by about 2,500 votes with 97 percent counted late Nov. 7, Action News 5 reports. Hyde-Smith says she is not conceding; Colom says his lawyers are ready. Hinds and DeSoto counties are reviewing thousands of ballots one by one. Certification is due Nov. 13.
  • Florida's 7th and 9th districts will not get automatic recounts: returns sent to the state Nov. 7 put Ryan Elijah up 0.503 percent, 1,631 votes, and Rep. Darren Soto up 0.53 percent, Central Florida Public Media reports. Overseas ballots can still shift totals.
Show all 60 updates
  • Rep. Lauren Boebert's lawyer Scott Gessler says her campaign is investigating very unusual voting patterns and expects a recount in Colorado's 4th, Colorado Politics reports Nov. 6. He gave no specifics. Eileen Laubacher led by 3,172 votes, 0.83 points. No suit is filed.
  • Lake City, S.C., Mayor Yamekia Robinson protested Nov. 5, saying city law requires a runoff since no one won a majority, and asked that no winner be certified. Florence County certified Larue Alford Nov. 6 and set a protest hearing for Nov. 10, WPDE reports.
  • South Carolina's 2nd District heads to a mandatory recount after certified results put Rep. Joe Wilson ahead of Zyon Khalifa by 0.99 points, under the 1 percent trigger, WACH reports Nov. 6. Democrats say State House Districts 27 and 89 also go to recounts. No suit is reported.
  • Miami-Dade's machine recount in Florida's 27th is set for 10 a.m. Nov. 10, CBS Miami reports. Rodriguez's suit also cites a photo of Supervisor Garcia with Salazar; Garcia says she poses with anyone who asks. No hearing is set. Salazar leads by 1,090.
  • Peltola's campaign sued Alaska's Division of Elections Nov. 6 under public records law for a register of rejected absentee ballots and why each was rejected, Alaska Public Media reports. The Department of Law says it need not release it. Peltola leads by about 600.
  • Colom led Hyde-Smith by 2,010 votes Nov. 6 in AP's count, the Mississippi Free Press reports. The NAACP urged county commissions to follow state law in counting and certifying, the Guardian reports. Harrison County rules on 1,448 affidavit ballots Nov. 10. No suit is filed.
  • Rodriguez sued Miami-Dade elections chief Alina Garcia in federal court Nov. 6 (S.D. Fla. 1:26-cv-27895) to remove her from the Florida 27th recount board, citing her son-in-law's work for Salazar, WLRN reports. Her office says there is no conflict. Salazar leads by 1,090.
  • Mississippi Senate: Colom led by about 1,800 late Nov. 5, CNN reports. Watson says ballots left are unknown; Republicans estimate up to 20,000. A Hinds County commissioner is rejecting some Jackson State students' affidavit ballots as wrong precinct.
  • Alabama: Camara Blue is seeking a recount in Jefferson County Commission District 3, down 593 votes to Jimmie Stephens, about 1.08 percent, WBRC reports. That is outside the 0.5 percent automatic margin, so he must petition and pay. No certification dispute is reported.
  • Eliott Rodriguez's lawyers asked Nov. 5 that Miami-Dade elections chief Alina Garcia recuse from Florida's 27th recount, citing her remark that Salazar wins with or without one. Garcia told CBS Miami she will not. Salazar leads by 1,116, WLRN reports. No suit is reported.
  • Colom's lawyer told all 82 Mississippi counties Nov. 5 not to separate accepted affidavit ballots, her letter shows, saying Hyde-Smith's demand has no basis in state law and would undermine ballot secrecy, WLOX reports. No suit is reported.
  • Mississippi GOP Chair Mike Hurst said Nov. 5 the Senate race is far from over, estimated 20,000 ballots unprocessed and said the party is ready to litigate, The Dispatch reports. Asked for evidence of a violation, he gave no details. No suit is reported.
  • Trump posted Nov. 5 that votes for the second Sullivan should go immediately to Sen. Sullivan, The National News Desk reports. No court or Alaska office is reported to have backed that. Alaska's ranked choice tally is Nov. 18 and certification is planned Nov. 25.
  • Lawyers for Sen. Hyde-Smith told all 82 Mississippi counties Nov. 5 to separate and preserve affidavit ballots as possible evidence in a contest or Senate proceeding, WLBT reports. Colom's campaign calls it a desperate stunt. Colom led by 1,724 Thursday. No suit is reported.
  • Minnesota's 1st: Jake Johnson leads Rep. Brad Finstad by 323 votes, FOX 9 reports. County boards canvass Nov. 6 to 13 and the state board meets Nov. 19; no recount can start before then. Finstad had not conceded or said if he will seek a recount as of Nov. 4.
  • Sen. Schumer is sending legal and other resources to Mississippi through the DSCC, Magnolia Tribune reports, citing Punchbowl News. Mississippi has no formal recount; a candidate can examine ballot boxes after certification, then sue, ABC News reports. No suit is filed.
  • North Carolina's 5th: Chuck Hubbard leads Rep. Virginia Foxx 139,034 to 138,935, WVEC reports, with up to 3,117 provisional ballots under review. Foxx says the count is not finished. County canvass is Nov. 13, then the trailing candidate can seek a recount.
  • Mississippi Democrats sued in DeSoto County Circuit Court late Nov. 3 over ballot shortages and late openings, then dropped the case Nov. 4, Magnolia Tribune reports, giving no reason. ABC News says mail ballots can arrive through Nov. 10. No suit over the count is reported.
  • Two more Florida House races sit just outside the 0.5 percent automatic recount margin, Central Florida Public Media reports: Ryan Elijah leads Bale Dalton by 0.53 percent in the 7th, and Rep. Darren Soto leads Dan Green by 0.52 percent in the 9th. Final tallies due this week.
  • Colom led Hyde-Smith by 1,138 votes the night of Nov. 4, Al Jazeera reports. Secretary of State Watson says about 3,600 mail ballots remain, plus affidavit ballots; counties certify by Nov. 13. Peltola led Sullivan by 637 with nearly a quarter of votes uncounted.
  • Mississippi's Senate gap was 65 votes Nov. 4, Forbes reports, with about 44,000 ballots left by NBC's estimate, per TPM. Colom has a recount fund. North Carolina's 7th: Rouzer leads by about 0.75 percent, inside the 1 percent recount margin; demands due Nov. 16.
  • Florida's 27th District is inside the 0.5 percent automatic recount margin: Miami-Dade's elections supervisor put Rep. Salazar's lead over Eliot Rodriguez at 0.46 percent, about 1,100 votes, WSVN reports. 202 mail ballots can be cured until 5 p.m. Nov. 5.
  • The Ninth Circuit docketed DOJ's Alaska appeal as No. 26-7304 on Nov. 4 with a routine schedule: opening brief Dec. 14, answering brief Jan. 11. That runs past the state's Nov. 25 certification target unless the court speeds it up.
  • Judge Kacsmaryk ordered Nov. 4 that the plaintiffs in the Potter County hand count suit refile their request for a preliminary injunction as a standalone motion by midnight CST Nov. 6. The suit seeks to bar Texas counties from certifying until paper ballots are hand counted.
  • Alaska's Senate gap stayed under the second Sullivan's vote Nov. 4, the test in DOJ's dismissed suit. Boston 25 had Sullivan up 1,677 with the second Sullivan at 3,448; AFP had Peltola up 626 with him at 3,583. Thousands of ballots remain.
  • Mississippi's Senate race: counties certify by Nov. 13 and the state declares results Dec. 3, the Mississippi Independent reports. A recount takes a court order. Colom's campaign estimates 10,000 to 15,000 affidavit ballots left, WLBT reports. No suit is reported.
  • Minnesota's 1st District is too close to call: Jake Johnson leads Rep. Brad Finstad by 324 votes in unofficial returns, about 0.10 points, MPR News reports. That is inside the 0.25 percent margin for a publicly funded recount. No request or dispute is reported.
  • Mississippi's U.S. Senate race is uncalled. Scott Colom led Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith by 43 votes at 2 a.m. Nov. 4, each near 463,000, Magnolia Tribune reports, with thousands of affidavit ballots left, which can take up to five business days. No recount or contest is reported.
  • Todd Blanche told Fox News Nov. 3 that Alaska's ballots should be preserved and could be checked one by one for voter confusion if Sullivan loses, Newsweek reports. Judge Gleason ruled setting aside ballots ranking the second Sullivan would violate the secret ballot.
  • Senior administration officials told CBS News Nov. 3 that Trump is not pressuring officials to withhold certification, and that officials will review results for irregularities. Alaska plans count updates Nov. 10, 13 and 18, Newsweek reports.
  • DOJ said Nov. 3 it is closely monitoring reports of alleged misconduct tied to the second Sullivan on Alaska's ballot, AP reports. Newsweek says the Senate count is close and the state aims to certify by Nov. 25. DOJ's appeal of the suit's dismissal is pending.
  • AP reports Democratic attorney Marc Elias and others were notified they may be targets of DOJ's Alaska Senate race probe. Elias says the administration has weaponized DOJ and cites zero evidence of wrongdoing. No charges are reported.
  • ABC News reports, citing sources, that DOJ has sent more than 100 subpoenas and at least 20 target letters in its Alaska Senate race probe. The letters go to Democrats investigators believe joined the candidate recruitment effort. No charges are reported.
  • A judge declined Nov. 2 to remove Bucks County Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia from the Pennsylvania county's election board, as Rep. Fitzpatrick sought, citing no statutory authority, the Inquirer reports. His lawyer says bias can still be raised before the board.
  • Judge Kacsmaryk set Nov. 4 and 5 deadlines for plaintiffs to answer the bids by the DSCC and DCCC and by voter groups to join the Potter County hand count suit. No injunction motion is on the docket, so no order touches the Nov. 3 count.
  • Judge Gleason dismissed DOJ's amended Alaska suit without prejudice Nov. 1, ruling it lacks standing because cast ballots are secret and commingled, so its relief is infeasible. The bid to block certification and segregate ballots fails. DOJ appealed the same day.
  • AP reports FBI agents contacted donors to candidate Daniel J. Sullivan in Petersburg and Sitka, Alaska, and Groton, Mass., asking if they were misled, as DOJ's Alaska Senate race probe widens. No charges are reported.
  • The state, Peltola's campaign with the DSCC, and the League of Women Voters of Alaska with Common Cause filed final replies Oct. 31, so the motions to dismiss DOJ's Alaska suit await Judge Gleason. The state called DOJ's bid to segregate ballots meritless and not even possible.
  • The NAACP Texas State Conference, League of Women Voters of Texas, MOVE Texas Civic Fund and Common Cause, represented by the ACLU and the Lawyers' Committee, moved Oct. 30 to join the Potter County hand count suit and filed a proposed motion to dismiss. No ruling yet.
  • DOJ asked Judge Gleason for a preliminary injunction ordering Alaska to segregate every ballot that ranks Daniel J. Sullivan, plus expedited discovery from the Peltola campaign and the DSCC, with a ruling by Nov. 2. The state opposes.
  • U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman confirmed new subpoenas and a surge of law enforcement in DOJ's Alaska Senate race probe, naming no crime. President Trump said Peltola and candidate Daniel J. Sullivan should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted. No ruling on dismissal.
  • Judge Gleason fast-tracked the three motions to dismiss DOJ's amended Alaska suit: DOJ's response was due 1 p.m. Oct. 30, replies by noon Oct. 31. In Texas, the DSCC and DCCC moved Oct. 29 to join the Potter County hand count suit as defendants.
  • Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy told NewsNation that if the Senate race is close, the state will have to take a look at certification while its probe of the Peltola campaign runs. The state still seeks dismissal of DOJ's suit.
  • Alaska, Peltola's campaign with the DSCC, and the League of Women Voters of Alaska with Common Cause each moved to dismiss DOJ's amended certification suit and asked Judge Gleason for a fast ruling. DOJ says the earlier motions are moot. No ruling yet.
  • DOJ amended its Alaska certification suit, citing a New York Times report and adding a Supremacy Clause claim that alleges a conspiracy over a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot. CBS reports new DOJ subpoenas in a related criminal probe; no one is charged.
  • Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered a state probe of whether Mary Peltola's campaign helped recruit candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., after a New York Times report DOJ also cites in its certification suit. That candidate denies it. No ruling in the suit yet.
  • Judge Gleason let Peltola's campaign and the DSCC join DOJ's Alaska certification suit and seek dismissal before the election. DOJ asked the court to pause certification pending an investigation. A dismissal ruling could come this week.
  • DOJ dropped its opposition to the Peltola campaign and DSCC joining its Alaska certification suit, citing a New York Times report on the race, and says it will seek expedited discovery from the campaign. It still opposes the League of Women Voters joining.
  • The Potter County GOP sued in federal court in Amarillo to bar Texas counties from certifying Nov. 3 federal results until every paper ballot statewide is hand counted. Judge Kacsmaryk has the case. No injunction motion yet.
  • DOJ opposed letting Peltola's campaign, the DSCC and the League of Women Voters of Alaska join its Alaska certification suit, saying the state already defends it. The state does not oppose the campaign or DSCC. Judge Gleason plans to rule on intervention by 5 p.m. Oct. 28.
  • Judge Gleason granted Alaska's request to fast-track its motion to dismiss DOJ's certification suit. DOJ must respond by 3 p.m. Oct. 29, and the state may reply by noon Oct. 30. No ruling on the merits yet.
  • Judge Gleason fast-tracked the Alaska certification suit, noting it came after voting began. DOJ must answer the intervention motions by 5 p.m. Oct. 27; replies are due noon Oct. 28. The state of Alaska also moved to dismiss and asked for a quick ruling.
  • Peltola's campaign and the DSCC filed a 27 page motion to dismiss DOJ's Alaska certification suit and asked Judge Gleason to rule before Election Day. Attorney General Todd Blanche told CNN the suit is not groundwork to overturn results. No ruling yet.
  • Mary Peltola's campaign and the Democrats' Senate campaign committee moved late Oct. 23 to join DOJ's Alaska certification suit and ask that it be dismissed. The League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause also seek to join. No ruling yet.
  • Trump said he ordered DOJ's suit to block certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race. Legal scholars quoted by Votebeat call it baseless. Judge Sharon Gleason has the case; no emergency motion or ruling yet.
  • Attorney General Blanche told reporters Oct. 22 he would not rule out DOJ action in state certification in a doomsday scenario, Fox News reports. He said he is not trying to stop an election from being certified.
  • Added Alaska: DOJ sued the state to block certification of the U.S. Senate race if Sen. Dan S. Sullivan loses and votes for a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan could have changed the result. No emergency motion yet.

What can I do?

Problem at the polls? Call 866-OUR-VOTE.

Call 866-OUR-VOTE
Every sign we look for

Early signs 3 of 3 observed

Signs the threat is taking shape.

Signs it is happening 0 of 3 observed

Signs the threat is actively occurring.

  • A county board votes to delay or refuse certification of a general election.

    Not observed yet

  • A court order is needed to force a county to certify.

    Not observed yet

  • Challenges to results are filed at the same time across several states.

    Not observed yet