Nonpartisan. Oath-bound. We endorse no candidate and no party.

Back to Rumor Control

The rumor is Misleading

Voter rolls and eligibility Nationwide

“New Justice Department charges prove noncitizens are voting in large numbers.”

The fact

Noncitizen voting is a crime, and it is rare.

On Nov. 2 the Justice Department announced charges against 63 people in election-related cases, most of them lawful permanent residents accused of voting as noncitizens, with the most in North Carolina (18) and California (12). DOJ counts 195 noncitizens charged in 25 states over nine weeks, while more than 150 million people voted in 2024. Charges are accusations, and each person is presumed innocent.

How this story developed

  1. Correction: the facts now lead with DOJ's Nov. 2 announcement of charges against 63 people, replacing the Oct. 29 indictment of 18 as the main figure.
  2. DOJ announces charges against 63 people in election-related cases in 15 states, most of them lawful permanent residents, Newsweek reports. It counts 195 noncitizens charged in 25 states over nine weeks. Charges are accusations.
  3. Federal prosecutors in West Tennessee charge two foreign nationals with unlawful voting, from Haywood and Fayette counties, in the 2022 and 2024 elections. Charges are accusations.

How we know: 19 sources

Official statements 7

  1. DOJ: Charges against 28 foreign nationals in California, Oct 19 Checked Archived copy
  2. Justice Department: 48 charged with election crimes in 5 states, Oct 26 Checked Archived copy

News reports 10

  1. Courthouse News: 28 charged, AG office puts it at 0.0001 percent, Oct 19 Checked Archived copy
  2. ABC7 Los Angeles: Operation Protect the Vote arrests in Commerce, Oct 19 Checked Archived copy

Fact-checks 1

  1. UW CIP: arrests spur mass noncitizen voting rumors, Oct 20 Checked Archived copy

Other 1

  1. U.S. Department of Justice Archived copy